Plesk Error: There is no IP address X in the pool

After a Plesk server crash, I migrated files over to a new server. When I log in to Plesk and click any domain name, I get the following error

Error: There is no IP address 82.165.179.137 in the pool.

The error is fixed by running the command

plesk bin subscription -u DOMAIN_HERE -ip 82.165.179.137